Friday, June 11, 2010

Who will feed over a billion mouths? If Not Farmers.

Over the years increasing agricultural output has created, if not practically but theoretically (what data say), a food surplus in India. More than 28 million ton of food grain are lying in the government’s godown and rest unable to get a government shelter are kept under the sky, on the mercy of weather, for rats, birds, insects and anything else that can survive on grains.

Despite surge in agriculture output and increasing prices of farm produce in the consumer market, farming has remained an unprofitable, high-risk business. After putting in their money, labour and everything else farmers have, they are far away from any kind of benefit. They are still on margin. Mute spectators watching everyone having their share except themselves.

Indian farmers are in acute distress. They are committing suicide—what they never did even during the British Raj. Whatever the reason may be but they are losing heavily. Sometimes the crop production may be good but they are forced to sell the produce at a price lower than the cost of inputs. According to the Punjab State Farmers’ Commission, in Punjab, farmers with two hectares of land are not even able to earn as much as a Class IVth employee. If this is the case of Punjab which supposedly the richest in terms of agriculture and farming, what would the scene in other states. No wonder if they leave the age old profession of farming and move out to cities for survival. Next time, I request you, please don’t crib if you see some more people flocking in your overcrowded city. They have no other choice. Either to migrate to cities or, in worse case, commit suicide.

Farmers’ subsistence is under attack from all the fronts – failure of monsoon, floods, poor infrastructure, lack of government support, climate change, ecological imbalances, increasing input cost, “Singurs” and special economic zones— which lead to incessant crop failure. In a study conducted by the National Sample Survey Organisation, over 40 percent farmers interviewed said they would like to quit farming if they had any alternative. The question is – if not farmers, who will feed a billion mouths? Who will stack godowns with food grains? Who will ensure food security to the nation? Do we want to wait for more farmers to commit suicide? Despite achieving a remarkable success of the Green Revolution and record-breaking food grain production over the years what went wrong with farming? Here issue is not about increasing agricultural productivity. The issue is about increasing the farmers’ monthly income. The issue is about making farming profitable at par with other businesses. It is about feeding sufficiently to those who feed more than a billion mouths everyday.

Agriculture production cannot be further increased unless we guarantee farmers remunerative prices for their farm produce. And this can be done only when the government comes up with crop insurance scheme along with minimum support price and credits at reasonable interest rates. The government should also give subsidies to insurance companies to take on crop insurance. This will certainly help farmers obtain benefits and encourage them to go in for cultivation instead of stopping production. Therefore, the fundamental focus of the government should be on giving emphasis on the economic well being of the men and women feeding the nation. Economic viability of farming has to be ensured by guaranteeing a minimum net income to a farmer. Only then can the nation guarantee increasing agriculture production to feed the increasing population.

Now an employee guarantee scheme has come but unfortunately, it is being implemented only when there are full-scale agricultural operations. And during this period there is a real dearth of people who can work in farms. This scheme should only be for the lean period when there are no agricultural operations going on. Here discussing National Rural Development Guarantee Act will be pertinent. Public Distribution System (PDS) and the NRDGA Act should go hand in hand to ensure that farmers obtain the grains for food when there is not farming at all. Therefore any employee guarantee scheme should be supplemented with PDS to provide a support system to remove hunger.

Dr. M.S. Swaminathan recommended a major non-farm employment initiative, both on farm, wherein agriculture productivity can be increased and thereby income. In the non-farm segment he suggested to create a more market-driven opportunities. The Khadi and Village Industries Commission is a small initiative in this direction. It is also suggested that the minimum support price should be the total cost of production plus 50 percent. Besides this, farmers who sell their produce to governments for PDS, ICDS and mid-day meal programmes must be given a smart card so that if the international prices or even some other prices go up, they should be compensated. The smart card can be a tool to ensure food security if the government retains a commanding height of the food security system. There is also a need to provide agriculture data that not only talk about yield per hectare but also net income per hectare (National Policy for Farmers 2008). To encourage the farming community, an award should also be declared for farmers who are the real custodians of sovereignty.

Meanwhile, agriculture planning in India needs to be all encompassing. It should also include animal husbandry and livestock. They are the major sources of income for farmers in various parts of the country. Moreover, scientific data suggest that with employing present technology – not with new technology – used in farming, 200 to 300 percent more production can be obtained from almost all rain-fed crops like jowar, bajra, ragi, millets, pulses and oilseeds. So the fact of increasing agriculture productivity lies in appropriate services and effective public bodies.

Now it becomes the responsibility of the central government, the state governments and people at large, to think dispassionately and act accordingly for the people who feed a nation with over a billion population.

6 comments:

  1. No Wealth for the poor, but we will host the Commonwealth Games.

    Logically speaking, India, with a population of more than 100 crores, should be home to the richest farmers in the world. The reason being that food is the basic requirement for all, so the consumption of edible items in India is huge. This should translate into high profits for farmers, but that is not the case. Traders procure the food produce at low rates from farmers and sell it at high rates. The irony is that food inflation is at an all time high, but farmers are being pushed to the brink of committing suicide. If the government has failed to do anything for the welfare of farmers, it is time for them to demonstrate their importance in society. One solution is that farmers can sell food directly to consumers at discounted retail prices. This will give the traders and organized retail outlets a run for their money. For doing this, farmers will need financial help from the government and banks so that they are able to reach the consumers directly. The government should stop using public money for funding an extravaganza such as the Commonwealth Games; the focus should be creating a Common ground of Wealth for everyone in society.

    India has roughly one-third of all poor people in the world, but millions of dollars have been diverted from schemes to fight poverty and used to fund the Commonwealth Games. According to a report, government spending on the games has gone out of control. Expenditure on sports infrastructure alone is more than 2000% of the amount that was initially allocated. To build the “showpiece” Athlete’s Village on the banks of Yamuna, around 100000 poor families living in the Yamuna Pushta slums, were displaced without providing them adequate shelter. Although the event is being promoted as Green Games, the reality is that after working hard at construction sites, the laborers return to a makeshift home to cook a meal over a smoky, open fire using whatever combustible material they can find. The government, on one hand talks of energy conservation and sustainable living, and on the other hand the games village is being constructed on the environmentally sensitive flood plain of the Yamuna.

    The Commonwealth Games are being organized in India just to show that we will soon become a developed country. The infrastructure is being developed in Delhi at the cost of higher taxes and an increased cost of living. The games have definitely given employment opportunities to the poor, but this is only temporary. The first priority should have been the welfare of the poor and then think of organizing world class sports events. Who really is cared about the plight of farmers and the poor, India is too busy in making the rich more rich and striving to pamper the foreign tourists with five star facilities.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am too happy to see you two doing such magnificent discussion on your blogs. And i have, instantly, become a huge fan of MG who never showed his argumentative side, while he was a colleague. MG by god ki kasam: you ROCK.

    Looking forward to see many more posts, although both of you made my skin crawl.

    I have some questions: will prices of food grains not affect poor? Can a poor farmer take charge of selling the produce? If rural employment guarantee scheme is a failure than what can we do to save poor farmers from suicide? shouldn’t we be saying: enough of schemes?

    The problem with market driven economy is that it incubates in environment conducive to growth. The service sector economy is helping rich and middle class in cities and adjoining areas. Tata wanted Nano in Bengal, Mamta wanted otherwise. Bengal’s farmers’ loss, (which they were made to believe was a gain), became Gujrat’s farmers’ gain.

    Dear Mr MG are you thinking about farmers or yourself as you have mentioned discounted food grains…;-) LOL

    Commonwealth games are a classic example of misplaced importance. We, as a nation and people, think too highly about ourselves. We should be, if not modest, practical enough to say, ‘we can’t organise it at this point in time.’ All the money spent on these games is such a waste.

    The city of Delhi lacked public transportation, which by and large is still in a state of mess. Resurfacing of roads, new dividers and face lifting the existing stadiums is all, we say ‘world class infrastructure for a world class event.’ Had we spent this money in putting a new all inclusive (rich, middle and poor) township in place with focus on employment, education and health for poor also, it would have been a good example of money well-spent. Everyone boasts new infrastructure in the NCR, where are we creating spaces for poor. How many Nano-like apartments have you seen? No marks for answering: ‘NO.’

    The model of our growth produces perfect fodder for Maoist propaganda. The PM says it’s the biggest internal security challenge faced by the nation. The question is what’s wrong? The answer is neither in the barrel of gun nor in another round of resurfacing of Delhi’s roads.

    Having Dal with a thin crest of Mother dairy ghee waiting with Chapatis, vegetables and rice, I am bound to slide into the belief that India is shining.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Really situation is more worse than what we have anticipated but what could be the solution that is more important than the anything else otherwise we will fall pray of analysis that happens more than often under Indian condition, as we see if one country move towards development the contribution of agriculture sector drops to the single digit of the state's GDP share so there we are bound to have a transition phase and economic disparity here international treaties signed by government and internal policies of state establishment becomes more pronounced than ever India as a country a group of heterogeneous society where most of the institutions are formed to appease one group or the other so at this setup it becomes highly impossible for them to remain vital for long consequently a goal displacement feeding on the government money generates more dissatisfaction among educated youth and to the grass root.To revive these defunct institutions including scientific research centers and financial groups is a must.As an agricultural country we should more focus on to address issues like how to enhance agricultural produce and better output for the farmers hitherto u did a lot of lip services and voter bank policies.In the process we created no. of structures viz soil testing centers agriclinics and seed testing centers but of no avail. We did not fix any accountabilities towards the people and the goverment so they prove mere white elephant.These organisations must be run on performance base or contract them out to save government money and tap our unused scientific talent.The farmer suicide cases in Andhra Pradesh because of two prominent reasons one is poor seed quality which was highly pesticide intensive,secondly lack of proper financial support from the government.Hence we have to frame policies not to cover up earlier blunders but to rectify them and to fill the yawning gap between need and the provision.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I thank you all for taking time out to write on an issue which often fails to attract the interest of our food and agriculture minister. No doubt cricket is more glamorous. It has everything that farming is starved of—money, media interest and people’s attention. Commonwealth games is all together a different issue. Had we invested the same amount (that we wasted in Commonwealth games) in water management we would have solved the problem of water crisis of the country forever (again this is an ideal situation) and might have helped our neighbours too (not a bad idea).

    I agree with Mohit’s idea of selling the farm produce directly into the market. But the question is how this can be done. Cooperatives had failed miserably in past and anything closer to that seems a distant dream. But I believe a modified model which brings in incentives for everyone associated minus conflict of interests will work. Rahul, I would say price rise of farm produce will not affect poor since 23 percent of them are somehow involved in farming and rest 19 percent live in urban areas. I think most of urban poor have come to cities from villages in search of jobs (I have no data to support my claim). They can be easily served by a strong public distribution network (I remember it was decent in our childhood. We used to buy sugar and wheat from government ration shop).

    Implementation of any policy at the ground level requires passion and commitment for the cause. We cannot expect the same from government officials, contractors and anyone else who does not have a feeling and respect for the very purpose of the policy. So I would say a big NO to any more policies.

    The saddest part of agriculture is that it has always been considered as a problem. All our actions have remained remedial and focused around solving an immediate hitch. We have never given a thought to the fact that this could also be a profit making business which can change the lives of millions. A complete overhaul in approach is required. We need to be more creative towards making agriculture a lucrative profession for an individual and increasing ROI. And this should be done without involving the government.

    ReplyDelete
  6. First of all I would like to thank Deepak for raising such an important issue. The article is really an informative and eye opening for the farmer’s pity condition in India.

    Frankly I do not have much knowledge and understanding of policies and economics around agricultural. However I belong to a village and I know 99% of villagers do not have information on these policies.

    I can still see below mentioned basic living facilities are missing in my village and almost all the villages in my region (Magadh region in Bihar).

    - No Power even after 64 years of independence.
    - Proper basic and primary education facility is missing.
    - Almost no medical facility except jhola chap doctors.
    - No canal system or proper water reservoir to mitigate drought or flood. For last three years farmers could not cultivate paddy in this region due to drought. Farmers are forced to buy rice from market to eat. Those who are supposed to feed others are buying from market. In this scenario think about their financial condition especially when they do not have any other means of earning.
    - No proper road connectivity between village and nearby market or district town.
    - No promotion of any kind of modern agricultural techniques.

    And Many more……………….What more you want to hear from me, I do not want to say that in current time also our farmers are forced to leave in stone age.

    I do not know whom to blame for this. Actually if you will ask me then first I will blame myself, then all the farmers and citizen of that region. Just don’t expect anything from anyone; we as Aam Aadmee have to fight against each and every odd to live as human of 21st century. We have to make this a mass movement, the way Gandhi made freedom from British a dream of every single Indian.

    ReplyDelete