Finally, government has decided to open the retail sector for 51% FDI in multi-brand stores and 100% in single brand stores. Mega retail giants like Wal-Mart can now open mega retail stores in India. It was expected. The government has been discussing the issue for over a decade. But the timing was a little bizarre. It has many other contentious issues to solve first than come up with another. Anyways they are the right people to judge what to do when (they think this way only ;-), and not us. So we should move on to our topic...FDI in retail. The decision has come with a few riders.
Many have welcomed the government’s decision. The government and the people who support FDI in retail, argue that FDI will create more jobs in retail and allied fields, provide farmers with better remuneration for their farm produce, help consumers save 5% to 10% on purchase, and develop supply chain and logistics infrastructure. They believe FDI in retail will give an overall boost to the entire retail sector (Says Reliance Retail; appeared in TOI, November 25, 2011). I think it is an overdose. Isn’t it?
The retail sector is already growing at the rate of 15% per annum, and contributes 13% to the country’s GDP. All this is happening with indigenous capital. So why has government decided to open the retail sector? Does it want Wal-Mart to have its share from the already booming retail sector? Or worse, the ministers have gone mad and considered Wal-Mart a substitute for Public Distribution System! Or the government wants foreign investors to do what it has failed in so far – to set up cold storage and warehouses in rural areas and protect farm produce from wastage. The decision could be a double edged sword.
There is no denying the fact that FDI in retail will create job opportunities directly in mega retail stores and allied areas. Big Bazaars, Spencer’s, and other retail chains have certainly created jobs for the unemployed youth. But will it able to create 3-4 million jobs directly in retail and another 4-6 million jobs in logistics and support services, as estimated by the government? Mega size retail stores with colossal investment capacity and technical knowhow will wipe out over crores of Kirana shops and the people who depend on them.
Mr. Prime Minister, do you think your decision will create over 1.5 crore jobs? And if you think Wal-Marts can do wonders, why America and other countries where they have shops are distressed? Why did Thailand need to bring a new legislation restricting Mega Store Chains from opening new shops in the country? And what happened to hundreds of shop that had flourished on the streets of Budapest before Wal-Mart entered Hungary? Previous experiences suggest that mega stores have been failed in creating new job opportunities and providing essential articles at lower rates than market.
It is said that Wal-Mart will procure farm produce directly from farmers. It means this process will eliminate middlemen and farmers will have larger share than earlier. Secondly, for efficient functioning, the company will also set up proper infrastructure, which will further benefit farmers. Thirdly, farmers will not have to go to mandi in order to sell their produce. And lastly, the company will provide farmers with training and other resources for better quality produce. AGREED. Can we ignore the fact the companies will always be looking for better bargains? And what if they choose the U.S. to import wheat (as its production cost in the U.S. is much lower than India) and go to Europe for something else where agriculture subsidy is more than 65%. More or less, FDI is not going to change farmers’ fate. They will continue to live under uncertainty.
We were apprehensive when automation was introduced in steel plants in the late 80s. We still remember the uproar over the introduction of computers in India. It was as if everyone were going to lose his job. New cars hit the road and ambassador disappeared without a slightest qualm. But remember they were not retail, which has a direct bearing upon masses and agriculture, on which depends more than 63% of our highly vulnerable population.
Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to suggest you one thing. Never take a decision based on the report prepared by some so called big company. They say American subprime crisis was the result of one such decision.
Many have welcomed the government’s decision. The government and the people who support FDI in retail, argue that FDI will create more jobs in retail and allied fields, provide farmers with better remuneration for their farm produce, help consumers save 5% to 10% on purchase, and develop supply chain and logistics infrastructure. They believe FDI in retail will give an overall boost to the entire retail sector (Says Reliance Retail; appeared in TOI, November 25, 2011). I think it is an overdose. Isn’t it?
The retail sector is already growing at the rate of 15% per annum, and contributes 13% to the country’s GDP. All this is happening with indigenous capital. So why has government decided to open the retail sector? Does it want Wal-Mart to have its share from the already booming retail sector? Or worse, the ministers have gone mad and considered Wal-Mart a substitute for Public Distribution System! Or the government wants foreign investors to do what it has failed in so far – to set up cold storage and warehouses in rural areas and protect farm produce from wastage. The decision could be a double edged sword.
There is no denying the fact that FDI in retail will create job opportunities directly in mega retail stores and allied areas. Big Bazaars, Spencer’s, and other retail chains have certainly created jobs for the unemployed youth. But will it able to create 3-4 million jobs directly in retail and another 4-6 million jobs in logistics and support services, as estimated by the government? Mega size retail stores with colossal investment capacity and technical knowhow will wipe out over crores of Kirana shops and the people who depend on them.
Mr. Prime Minister, do you think your decision will create over 1.5 crore jobs? And if you think Wal-Marts can do wonders, why America and other countries where they have shops are distressed? Why did Thailand need to bring a new legislation restricting Mega Store Chains from opening new shops in the country? And what happened to hundreds of shop that had flourished on the streets of Budapest before Wal-Mart entered Hungary? Previous experiences suggest that mega stores have been failed in creating new job opportunities and providing essential articles at lower rates than market.
It is said that Wal-Mart will procure farm produce directly from farmers. It means this process will eliminate middlemen and farmers will have larger share than earlier. Secondly, for efficient functioning, the company will also set up proper infrastructure, which will further benefit farmers. Thirdly, farmers will not have to go to mandi in order to sell their produce. And lastly, the company will provide farmers with training and other resources for better quality produce. AGREED. Can we ignore the fact the companies will always be looking for better bargains? And what if they choose the U.S. to import wheat (as its production cost in the U.S. is much lower than India) and go to Europe for something else where agriculture subsidy is more than 65%. More or less, FDI is not going to change farmers’ fate. They will continue to live under uncertainty.
We were apprehensive when automation was introduced in steel plants in the late 80s. We still remember the uproar over the introduction of computers in India. It was as if everyone were going to lose his job. New cars hit the road and ambassador disappeared without a slightest qualm. But remember they were not retail, which has a direct bearing upon masses and agriculture, on which depends more than 63% of our highly vulnerable population.
Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to suggest you one thing. Never take a decision based on the report prepared by some so called big company. They say American subprime crisis was the result of one such decision.