Saturday, November 26, 2011

FDI in Retail: A Double Edged Sword

Finally, government has decided to open the retail sector for 51% FDI in multi-brand stores and 100% in single brand stores. Mega retail giants like Wal-Mart can now open mega retail stores in India. It was expected. The government has been discussing the issue for over a decade. But the timing was a little bizarre. It has many other contentious issues to solve first than come up with another. Anyways they are the right people to judge what to do when (they think this way only ;-), and not us. So we should move on to our topic...FDI in retail. The decision has come with a few riders.

Many have welcomed the government’s decision. The government and the people who support FDI in retail, argue that FDI will create more jobs in retail and allied fields, provide farmers with better remuneration for their farm produce, help consumers save 5% to 10% on purchase, and develop supply chain and logistics infrastructure. They believe FDI in retail will give an overall boost to the entire retail sector (Says Reliance Retail; appeared in TOI, November 25, 2011). I think it is an overdose. Isn’t it?

The retail sector is already growing at the rate of 15% per annum, and contributes 13% to the country’s GDP. All this is happening with indigenous capital. So why has government decided to open the retail sector? Does it want Wal-Mart to have its share from the already booming retail sector? Or worse, the ministers have gone mad and considered Wal-Mart a substitute for Public Distribution System! Or the government wants foreign investors to do what it has failed in so far – to set up cold storage and warehouses in rural areas and protect farm produce from wastage. The decision could be a double edged sword.

There is no denying the fact that FDI in retail will create job opportunities directly in mega retail stores and allied areas. Big Bazaars, Spencer’s, and other retail chains have certainly created jobs for the unemployed youth. But will it able to create 3-4 million jobs directly in retail and another 4-6 million jobs in logistics and support services, as estimated by the government? Mega size retail stores with colossal investment capacity and technical knowhow will wipe out over crores of Kirana shops and the people who depend on them.

Mr. Prime Minister, do you think your decision will create over 1.5 crore jobs? And if you think Wal-Marts can do wonders, why America and other countries where they have shops are distressed? Why did Thailand need to bring a new legislation restricting Mega Store Chains from opening new shops in the country? And what happened to hundreds of shop that had flourished on the streets of Budapest before Wal-Mart entered Hungary? Previous experiences suggest that mega stores have been failed in creating new job opportunities and providing essential articles at lower rates than market.

It is said that Wal-Mart will procure farm produce directly from farmers. It means this process will eliminate middlemen and farmers will have larger share than earlier. Secondly, for efficient functioning, the company will also set up proper infrastructure, which will further benefit farmers. Thirdly, farmers will not have to go to mandi in order to sell their produce. And lastly, the company will provide farmers with training and other resources for better quality produce. AGREED. Can we ignore the fact the companies will always be looking for better bargains? And what if they choose the U.S. to import wheat (as its production cost in the U.S. is much lower than India) and go to Europe for something else where agriculture subsidy is more than 65%. More or less, FDI is not going to change farmers’ fate. They will continue to live under uncertainty.

We were apprehensive when automation was introduced in steel plants in the late 80s. We still remember the uproar over the introduction of computers in India. It was as if everyone were going to lose his job. New cars hit the road and ambassador disappeared without a slightest qualm. But remember they were not retail, which has a direct bearing upon masses and agriculture, on which depends more than 63% of our highly vulnerable population.

Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to suggest you one thing. Never take a decision based on the report prepared by some so called big company. They say American subprime crisis was the result of one such decision.

Monday, May 16, 2011

Why Should We Thank Anna?

Many of you may not be a fan of Anna Hazare. But I feel, we must acknowledge his efforts to breathe life into Lokpal, who has been the victim of politics for quite a long time. Perhaps, our politicians were a little apprehensive of him. Or may be they were not sure of their integrity. They always found one or another reason to keep him where he was – in reports, recommendations, suggestions, half-done legislative bills, speeches, election manifestoes, and so on so forth.

The Administrative Reform Commission set up in 1966 recommended the formation of a two tier machinery of Lokpal and Lokayuktas, the former to deal with complaints against Ministries and Secretaries to the Government at the Centre and in the States, and the latter to deal with complaints against other officials. The Lokpal Bill was tabled on the floor of Lok Sabha on a number of occasions, but with a strong will of not making it a law and an independent agency with a strong paw and effective teeth. In 1971, the Congress Government introduced a seemingly half-hearted Lok Pal Bill in Lok Sabha. The Bill did not have any provision whereby the Lokpal could inquire into any charges against the PM. The Janta Party Government took a serious note and introduced the amended Bill, which brought the PM within the orbit of inquiry by the Lokpal. Alas! The government was ejaculated prematurely out of the power without taking the pleasure of being in the centre for long. And finally the Bill lapsed with the dissolution of the Lower House.

The Rajeev Gandhi government revived the proposal and introduced the Bill in Parliament in 1985. But this could not be enacted (If you remember Rajiv Gandhi Government had 403 MP’s and the Congress Party had its governments in more than two-third of states. With such a sweeping majority, they could have possibly changed the entire Constitution). The short-lived Janta Dal governments, firstly in 1989 and again in 1996, couldn’t contribute anything to the Bill. They were fighting for their own survival and struggling to keep their farmer PM awake. Likewise, the nationalist BJP had some other plans. They wanted to keep its Face above the rest. And in result, on the recommendation of the National Commission on the Constitution headed by Congress dissident, P.A. Sangma, the BJP government kept PM out of the purview of the Lokpal. Sadly, the BJP government had ambitions of a million men with the willpower of none. The Bill lapsed again in 2004. We should thank Anna for reviving the issue, bringing it to the centre stage of politics again and compelling the government to make some sincere commitments. Shouldn’t we?


Since 1966 (the year ARC recommended the formation of Lokpal), we have seen scams of all kinds –big, small, political, apolitical, civilian, military, corporate, labour, etc. But you cannot deny the fact that no serious attempt has been made to curb corruption. Political parties fight but to win elections. They have never taken a serious attempt against large scale grafts. Their target has always been the corrupt for mischievous political gains. And this is the failure of our political system.

Monday, April 25, 2011

Mirror

The cricket world cup ended on a high note with India winning the cup the second time. But Anna’s inning was far better than Yuvraj’s and Sachin’s. He played with meticulous timing. People on Jantar Mantar shouted, recited, sang, danced and cheered to support him. Anna and associates represented the people of India and their sentiments. The win was indeed bigger than the world cup.


Everyone was fed up with the prevailing corruption but, barring a few exceptions, nobody had come forward to raise a voice against it. Perhaps the voice was stuck somewhere in the vocal cord, suffocating our conscience. The fast unto death of Anna Hazare gave an outlet to the boiling anger accumulating within us with a series of scams one after another. CWG was completely a mass looting. 2G scam broke all the previous records. The big ghotala in subsidized food and fuel for the poor amounts to $40 billion. We count bodies after wars, terrorist attacks, earthquakes and cyclones. But we have never calculated how many have sacrificed their lives due to cruel corruption. I guess the numbers will surpass the deadliest of calamities.


It would be very unfair to say that corruption is limited only to the rich and the powerful. It is everywhere. It has made a silent entry into our life-cycle, early from birth to the penultimate rituals. Bribing for birth certificate is known to all of us. A friend of mine paid Rs. 60,000 for her son’s admission in a prestigious school in Vasant Kunj. This is not only with her. Whenever opportunities come, we all fall in the same line – shortcuts to get things done. This is the basic character of almost everyone Indian and the root cause of corruption in the country. We never try to go into details. Never try to find out how we can make our Driving License ourselves. We hire an agent who charges something and we get our DL. We follow the same path with so many other things. (To see log on to www.ipaidabribe.com)


Let me ask you a very simple question. How many of you follow traffic rules and never jump a red light even when no one is around? How many of you never pick or make a call while driving? We actually lack the basic ingredients of being a responsible citizen. We never respect the law. We are not alert. Not even alive. We are dead. Not clinically but morally and ethically. We give others the space to play around with our rights and privileges. And we pass on this trait from one generation to another, making it our national character, our culture. This gives audacity to Netas/Businessmen/Babus/Clerks to go absolute and corrupt. Before a revolution against corruption, we need an internal revolution. We must introspect and reflect for self purification. When we are righteous and morally strong we can go all out against corruption.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

A Tale of Teenage Bravery

I don’t remember when I studied the story of courage and audacity of sixteen brave hearts that left the British government in jitters. I did study history in my schooldays, but somehow missed out on this one. Did I? Nay! It wasn’t there in the history syllabus. In the school board, history was full of European and American history (I do remember Boston Tea Party), which I couldn’t connect with, ever. Thanks to my great history teachers (!), who didn’t know how to teach such a beautiful subject. Later I couldn’t get chance to study Indian history and Indian National Movement. But this story of the brave-hearts only got a passing reference. They were less talked about. And I think we should be grateful to Ashutosh Gowarikar for bringing out this forgotten tale of unmatched bravery of a handful of daring youth and presenting the narrative as it was; which is a rarity in the India cinema.

Based on the book “Do and Die: The Chittagong Uprising 1930 – 34,” by Manini Chatterjee, the movie “Khelein Hum Jee Jaan Sey” did a full justice to the gallantry of a gang of teenage radicals led by their school teacher Surjya Sen who in a single night jostled the British Raj by their unanticipated, guerilla-type raid with country made bombs and guns on all the colonial symbols in Chittagong (where recently, Bangaldesh defeated England in a thrilling World Cup Match). The movie is a wonderful piece of art, a story told straight from the heart, without any glam-sham, plain, and uncluttered as if it were not made to earn profit, but to do justice to the story and pay a tribute to the freedom fighters.


While going out to watch the movie on the very first day of its release (though it wasn’t the first show), I had a great expectation from him, for he had had created some outstanding works in the past, and I must say whenever he comes up with something new he carries the burden of those beautiful films. He might have not repeated the same this time for many, but I liked the KHJJS very much. It was worth spending your 3 hours and Rs. 200. If you haven’t watched the movie yet, just go out, not for Abhishek Bachchan or Deepika Padukone, but for Surjya Sen, Nirmal Sen, Pritilata Waddedar, and 16 other young brave hearts.

Friday, June 11, 2010

Who will feed over a billion mouths? If Not Farmers.

Over the years increasing agricultural output has created, if not practically but theoretically (what data say), a food surplus in India. More than 28 million ton of food grain are lying in the government’s godown and rest unable to get a government shelter are kept under the sky, on the mercy of weather, for rats, birds, insects and anything else that can survive on grains.

Despite surge in agriculture output and increasing prices of farm produce in the consumer market, farming has remained an unprofitable, high-risk business. After putting in their money, labour and everything else farmers have, they are far away from any kind of benefit. They are still on margin. Mute spectators watching everyone having their share except themselves.

Indian farmers are in acute distress. They are committing suicide—what they never did even during the British Raj. Whatever the reason may be but they are losing heavily. Sometimes the crop production may be good but they are forced to sell the produce at a price lower than the cost of inputs. According to the Punjab State Farmers’ Commission, in Punjab, farmers with two hectares of land are not even able to earn as much as a Class IVth employee. If this is the case of Punjab which supposedly the richest in terms of agriculture and farming, what would the scene in other states. No wonder if they leave the age old profession of farming and move out to cities for survival. Next time, I request you, please don’t crib if you see some more people flocking in your overcrowded city. They have no other choice. Either to migrate to cities or, in worse case, commit suicide.

Farmers’ subsistence is under attack from all the fronts – failure of monsoon, floods, poor infrastructure, lack of government support, climate change, ecological imbalances, increasing input cost, “Singurs” and special economic zones— which lead to incessant crop failure. In a study conducted by the National Sample Survey Organisation, over 40 percent farmers interviewed said they would like to quit farming if they had any alternative. The question is – if not farmers, who will feed a billion mouths? Who will stack godowns with food grains? Who will ensure food security to the nation? Do we want to wait for more farmers to commit suicide? Despite achieving a remarkable success of the Green Revolution and record-breaking food grain production over the years what went wrong with farming? Here issue is not about increasing agricultural productivity. The issue is about increasing the farmers’ monthly income. The issue is about making farming profitable at par with other businesses. It is about feeding sufficiently to those who feed more than a billion mouths everyday.

Agriculture production cannot be further increased unless we guarantee farmers remunerative prices for their farm produce. And this can be done only when the government comes up with crop insurance scheme along with minimum support price and credits at reasonable interest rates. The government should also give subsidies to insurance companies to take on crop insurance. This will certainly help farmers obtain benefits and encourage them to go in for cultivation instead of stopping production. Therefore, the fundamental focus of the government should be on giving emphasis on the economic well being of the men and women feeding the nation. Economic viability of farming has to be ensured by guaranteeing a minimum net income to a farmer. Only then can the nation guarantee increasing agriculture production to feed the increasing population.

Now an employee guarantee scheme has come but unfortunately, it is being implemented only when there are full-scale agricultural operations. And during this period there is a real dearth of people who can work in farms. This scheme should only be for the lean period when there are no agricultural operations going on. Here discussing National Rural Development Guarantee Act will be pertinent. Public Distribution System (PDS) and the NRDGA Act should go hand in hand to ensure that farmers obtain the grains for food when there is not farming at all. Therefore any employee guarantee scheme should be supplemented with PDS to provide a support system to remove hunger.

Dr. M.S. Swaminathan recommended a major non-farm employment initiative, both on farm, wherein agriculture productivity can be increased and thereby income. In the non-farm segment he suggested to create a more market-driven opportunities. The Khadi and Village Industries Commission is a small initiative in this direction. It is also suggested that the minimum support price should be the total cost of production plus 50 percent. Besides this, farmers who sell their produce to governments for PDS, ICDS and mid-day meal programmes must be given a smart card so that if the international prices or even some other prices go up, they should be compensated. The smart card can be a tool to ensure food security if the government retains a commanding height of the food security system. There is also a need to provide agriculture data that not only talk about yield per hectare but also net income per hectare (National Policy for Farmers 2008). To encourage the farming community, an award should also be declared for farmers who are the real custodians of sovereignty.

Meanwhile, agriculture planning in India needs to be all encompassing. It should also include animal husbandry and livestock. They are the major sources of income for farmers in various parts of the country. Moreover, scientific data suggest that with employing present technology – not with new technology – used in farming, 200 to 300 percent more production can be obtained from almost all rain-fed crops like jowar, bajra, ragi, millets, pulses and oilseeds. So the fact of increasing agriculture productivity lies in appropriate services and effective public bodies.

Now it becomes the responsibility of the central government, the state governments and people at large, to think dispassionately and act accordingly for the people who feed a nation with over a billion population.