Saturday, December 28, 2013

Has anything changed yet?

Exactly a year back, the brutal rape and murder of a 23 year old girl in Delhi sent shockwaves across India and spurred street protests, nation-wide debate on women’s safety, and demand for more stringent laws to punish the guilty. In subsequent months, owning to the public anger and media pressure, both Central and Delhi Governments announced a series of measures to ensure women’s safety in Delhi-NCR and all around the country: setting up women help-lines; 181 help line at Chief Minister’s Office; fast-track courts for speedy trials; and amendment in the India Penal Code, Indian Evidence Act, and Code of Criminal Procedure on laws related to sexual offences. But after all these necessary steps, has India become a safer place for women?

Let’s just take an example of Delhi. Incidences of rape and sexual assaults against women have doubled in the capital within a year. In 2012, there were 642 reported cases of rape and sexual violence which notched up to 1,472 by the end of October 2013. Similarly, cases of molestation and eve-teasing (a widely criticized word by women’s right activists , but it is still being used) have also gone up. In fact, despite so many cases of rape and violence against women, the situation has worsened in the last one year.  There are no CCTVs in buses as yet; roads are still unsafe for women, more PCR vans still to be added to the fleet, to reach the promised figure of 1000 PCR vans in Delhi; and what to speak of autowallas? They go by their own rules and regulations. Ironically, the central government has also forgotten what it has promised.  

While presenting the Union Budget 2013-14 in the lower house of Parliament, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram announced setting up a 1000-crore Nirbhaya Fund for safety and empowerment of women.  But, unfortunately not a rupee has been spent by the government from the 1000-crore fund until today. Recently, the Home Ministry has only received proposals from Ministries of Information Technology, Roads Transport & Highways, and Railways regarding how to utilize the fund. The government’s lethargy and the public inaction on this particular issue show how little we, as a nation, have moved forward since the gruesome incident.


If not today may be tomorrow, the government will come up with plans to spend this fund. But will that be enough to ensure women’s safety and prevent rapes and sexual assaults against women?  It is unquestionable that SOS button on mobile handsets, CCTV cameras on roads and public places, GPS in public places will be great and effective deterrent, but surely they are not going to prevent crimes.  To prevent sexual assaults against women and young girls, there is a need to change people’s mindset and their attitude towards women; to sensitize the police, the medical fraternity, and the judicial system; to educate half of India about other half’s needs and aspirations; to ensure equity at workplace, home and school; to bring in more women to the mainstream; and to inspire every individual to join hands to make a safer and better society. It is a colossal task, but not impossible. We must strive to ensure not only their safety but also dignity. 

Friday, July 27, 2012

Gogoi Fiddled while Assam Burned


For the last two months, Assam has been in news for all wrong reasons. First the massive flood killed over 121 people and 500 Kaziranga animals in Jorhat, Dhubri, Golaghat, and Nagaon districts. The flood was still dominating the prominent spaces in regional sections of national dailies when appeared another indecent incident of a girl’s molestation in the heart of the state, allegedly staged by a journalist of a local newspaper. This shameful act by a bunch of scoundrels was stilled condemned and criticized by the permanent settlers of online space, twitteraties, and facebookites when we heard the news of communal/ethnic violence in the western and lower districts of Assam. It is reported that over 42 people have been killed and around 2 lac people have left their villages, and are living as refugees in their own country. The recent violence is a perfect case of an old saying, “Nero Fiddled while Rome Burned.” The government’s apathy on all above cases is quite evident. Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi took over a week to decide whether army should be called for or not!

Communal violence is not a rarity in Assam. It happens at regular intervals. In 2008, around 36 people were killed in a clash between the Bodo community and Muslims, in Udalguri and Goalpara districts. If you look at the figures and talk to the people of the region you will clearly understand the situations and dynamics which create ethnic and communal violence in the state. Changing demographic profile, infiltration (cross boarder migration) from Bangladesh, the government’s inability to control flood which causes havoc every year, lack of economic development, and government’s perpetual indifference toward tribal people (this is applicable all over India), are the some of the basic reasons of what’s happening in Assam today.

The religious composition of the state’s population has gone through dramatic shift since 1951. After Jammu & Kashmir, Assam has the highest proportion of Muslim population (30.9% of total population) in India. Strikingly, between 1951 and 2001, the Muslim population increased by 6% and the Hindu population decreased by 7.2% in the state. District-wise analysis presents even better picture. The Muslim population increased from 42.9% in 1951 to 51.3% in 2001 in Goalpara, 29.3% to 34.9 % in Kamrup, 17.2% to 25.2% in Darrang, 40.5% to 50.1% in Nowgong, 5.8% to 6.9% in Sibsagar, and from 38.5% to 45.5% in Cachar district. During the same period, Hindu population decreased from 51.5% to 43.3% in Goalpara, 69.7% to 63.4% in Kamrup, 78.6% to 67.7% in Darrang, 58.4% to 48.9% in Nowgong, 92% to 89% in Sibsagar, and 60.6% to 52.8% in Cachar District. According to the study, “The Change of Religion and Language Composition in the State of Assam in Northeast India: A Statistical Analysis since 1951 to 2001,” by Dr. Bhupen Kumar Nath and Prof. Dilip C. Nath (published in International Journal of Scientific & Research Publications, Volume 2, Issue 5, May 2012), “Hindu and other religion may become minority in Assam after 2040 in comparison to combined proportion of Muslim and Christian population.” Certainly, fast changing demographic profile of the state is a major concern in the Hindu community. This concern is more profound in tribal communities. No major in- or out- migration of Muslim population is observed in the state and their population has increased whereas the Hindu population has decreased in all districts. This simply means either the natural growth rate of Muslim population is too high or there is massive infiltration from Bangladesh to neighboring border districts of Assam. Home Secretary R.K. Singh was heard saying that India-Bangladesh boarder is sealed and no one can cross the boarder. But can he answer how Abu Jundal managed to cross over the boarder near Benapur in Murshidabad district to reach Dhaka? Here I would like to add one thing: nothing can be worse than saying your own people Bangladeshi. And I believe this is happening in our country.

Explosive growth of population has created immense pressure on the meager resources of the state. Natural disasters like flood, abetted by the government’s sluggish responses, worsen the situation and create a strained society. The recent flood in the state caused a major exodus of population from water logged areas to the safer place. Perhaps the temporary movement of people must have certain bearing on the recent violence. Population becomes liability if it doesn’t contribute significantly to the development of the region. It is a bitter truth (you may call it inhumane approach) – as true as Bob.

It is said Bodo people and Muslims, who had came to this region after partition and after that, co-existed peacefully in the lower Assam. But over the years, the latter outnumbered the former, developed political clout (in Democracy, numbers do count), and was used by political parties to gain electoral mileage. It is really disgusting that Congress has been in power for almost 12 consecutive years and the CM emphasizes the need for development. What the hell was he doing for so many years?

Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Success is the outcome of hard work! WHAT??

A very good friend of mine, Sandipan Roy, once wrote on his wall, “Luck is a poor excuse…to duck your failures.” I guess many of you agree to this. Don’t you?

There’re good many people who believe blaming (bad) luck for failures is merely an excuse. And so is giving (good) luck the credit for success. They believe success is the outcome of hard work; slogging day and night. Isn’t it? Even I agree to this fact. Indeed hard work pays; but only up to a certain extent.

Luck is not so very important where the nature of the work is of regulatory kind (for example clerk, primary school teacher, receptionist, accountant, etc). In other words, we can say: luck seldom works in the world of mediocrity. (Nassim Nicholas Taleb, the author of the books, “Black Swan” and “Fooled by Randomness” has used the word “mediocristan”). It’s the least risky field, and has few possibilities of scalability. It’s believed if there’re lesser chances of disproportionate success (or being disproportionately lucky) in the world of mediocrity, then there’re few chances of disproportionate failure (or being disproportionately unlucky) as well.    

Luck becomes an important factor when the slightest of difference results disproportionate outcomes. Skill is important, but more or less it is luck/chance that makes all the difference—especially in stocks, writing, arts, cinema, sports, medicine, and other creative fields. Here the winner takes all.

 I’ve seen many people (and you must have seen as well) who are skilled, good at work, but from a general point of view, they’re not so lucky. It’s what that keeps them behind (in the rat race)? Do they fail in networking or (in other words) in exposing them to better opportunities? Or they just can’t control their life? Perhaps, the fields wherein luck becomes a major factor in success or failure are largely (or up to an extent) controlled by externalities. This can be explained by a very simple example.

Our body has two kinds of muscles: voluntary and involuntary. We can control voluntary muscles (striated or skeletal muscles) but we can’t control our heart, means we can’t increase or decrease its beat. It’s also difficult to avoid a nature’s call. Can you? In the similar way, our life is directly and indirectly influenced by so many things which are beyond our control. Can you control petrol price? In most of the time we take our best efforts. But, sometimes, the result of our work depends on some other things that are unknown. Nassim Taleb says, “Life is not a casino where the probabilities are known. In real life you do not know the odds…and the sources of uncertainty are not defined.”

Remember the chopper crash in Faridabad. Having finished the dinner the three women went up to the roof top, not to relax but to become the victim of a helicopter that crashed and landed on them. Unfortunately, they could not run faster than the speed at which an object falls under the gravity (which means they did not know their limitations!?!) and died. So “please do not underestimate the role of luck in life.” Luck (whether good or bad) is momentary so is life or vice versa.

J K Rowling had to accept more than 10 rejections before finally receiving a letter of acceptance from the publisher for her Harry Potter series. Her repeated rejections were sign of bad luck, acceptance a sign of good luck, and finally becoming a billionaire by writing was her destiny.


Sunday, February 12, 2012

Sapne

Sachhe sapne
Kachhe sapne
Pure sapne
Adhure sapne
Adhkulee ankho ke anbujhe sapne

Bebas sapne
Bebak sapne
Bhagti jindagi mein pichhe chhut jate azad sapne

Pak sapne
Gustakh sapne
Ankho mein base beintahn sapne

Anjan sapne jo anayas ban jate apne sapne
Aaj sabhi hai apne; par fir bhi hain sapne.

Thursday, February 9, 2012

What used to be acres has now been reduced to square foot

Eyes glued to the dry, flickering computer screen, mind wandering through the cobweb of long spreadsheet, and a parallel thought running in the hind side contemplating to wind up things before it is too late; all this coupled with today’s 24x7 kind of lifestyle is taking its toll on the overall mental and physical health. Moreover, in the last one-and-half decade, food habits have also gone through a sea change. People are now consuming red meat, fat, alcoholic beverages, carbohydrate, and packaged food more than ever before. The modern day stress, unhealthy lifestyle, busy schedule and extending working hours are causing new age diseases that were unknown in the past. Diabetes, hypertension, anxiety, stress disorders, Vitamin D deficiency, thrombosis – there are many more which are even difficult to spell out correctly. Their wrath has not even spared the elderly and the kid. The situation is more deplorable in mega cities where they are left with spaces not even sufficient to stretch legs. Indeed, what used to be acres has now been reduced to square foot. At places acres are left but for few. Do you still think in situation like this you can replenish your mind, body and soul, and live a life that is really full of life?

Saturday, November 26, 2011

FDI in Retail: A Double Edged Sword

Finally, government has decided to open the retail sector for 51% FDI in multi-brand stores and 100% in single brand stores. Mega retail giants like Wal-Mart can now open mega retail stores in India. It was expected. The government has been discussing the issue for over a decade. But the timing was a little bizarre. It has many other contentious issues to solve first than come up with another. Anyways they are the right people to judge what to do when (they think this way only ;-), and not us. So we should move on to our topic...FDI in retail. The decision has come with a few riders.

Many have welcomed the government’s decision. The government and the people who support FDI in retail, argue that FDI will create more jobs in retail and allied fields, provide farmers with better remuneration for their farm produce, help consumers save 5% to 10% on purchase, and develop supply chain and logistics infrastructure. They believe FDI in retail will give an overall boost to the entire retail sector (Says Reliance Retail; appeared in TOI, November 25, 2011). I think it is an overdose. Isn’t it?

The retail sector is already growing at the rate of 15% per annum, and contributes 13% to the country’s GDP. All this is happening with indigenous capital. So why has government decided to open the retail sector? Does it want Wal-Mart to have its share from the already booming retail sector? Or worse, the ministers have gone mad and considered Wal-Mart a substitute for Public Distribution System! Or the government wants foreign investors to do what it has failed in so far – to set up cold storage and warehouses in rural areas and protect farm produce from wastage. The decision could be a double edged sword.

There is no denying the fact that FDI in retail will create job opportunities directly in mega retail stores and allied areas. Big Bazaars, Spencer’s, and other retail chains have certainly created jobs for the unemployed youth. But will it able to create 3-4 million jobs directly in retail and another 4-6 million jobs in logistics and support services, as estimated by the government? Mega size retail stores with colossal investment capacity and technical knowhow will wipe out over crores of Kirana shops and the people who depend on them.

Mr. Prime Minister, do you think your decision will create over 1.5 crore jobs? And if you think Wal-Marts can do wonders, why America and other countries where they have shops are distressed? Why did Thailand need to bring a new legislation restricting Mega Store Chains from opening new shops in the country? And what happened to hundreds of shop that had flourished on the streets of Budapest before Wal-Mart entered Hungary? Previous experiences suggest that mega stores have been failed in creating new job opportunities and providing essential articles at lower rates than market.

It is said that Wal-Mart will procure farm produce directly from farmers. It means this process will eliminate middlemen and farmers will have larger share than earlier. Secondly, for efficient functioning, the company will also set up proper infrastructure, which will further benefit farmers. Thirdly, farmers will not have to go to mandi in order to sell their produce. And lastly, the company will provide farmers with training and other resources for better quality produce. AGREED. Can we ignore the fact the companies will always be looking for better bargains? And what if they choose the U.S. to import wheat (as its production cost in the U.S. is much lower than India) and go to Europe for something else where agriculture subsidy is more than 65%. More or less, FDI is not going to change farmers’ fate. They will continue to live under uncertainty.

We were apprehensive when automation was introduced in steel plants in the late 80s. We still remember the uproar over the introduction of computers in India. It was as if everyone were going to lose his job. New cars hit the road and ambassador disappeared without a slightest qualm. But remember they were not retail, which has a direct bearing upon masses and agriculture, on which depends more than 63% of our highly vulnerable population.

Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to suggest you one thing. Never take a decision based on the report prepared by some so called big company. They say American subprime crisis was the result of one such decision.

Monday, May 16, 2011

Why Should We Thank Anna?

Many of you may not be a fan of Anna Hazare. But I feel, we must acknowledge his efforts to breathe life into Lokpal, who has been the victim of politics for quite a long time. Perhaps, our politicians were a little apprehensive of him. Or may be they were not sure of their integrity. They always found one or another reason to keep him where he was – in reports, recommendations, suggestions, half-done legislative bills, speeches, election manifestoes, and so on so forth.

The Administrative Reform Commission set up in 1966 recommended the formation of a two tier machinery of Lokpal and Lokayuktas, the former to deal with complaints against Ministries and Secretaries to the Government at the Centre and in the States, and the latter to deal with complaints against other officials. The Lokpal Bill was tabled on the floor of Lok Sabha on a number of occasions, but with a strong will of not making it a law and an independent agency with a strong paw and effective teeth. In 1971, the Congress Government introduced a seemingly half-hearted Lok Pal Bill in Lok Sabha. The Bill did not have any provision whereby the Lokpal could inquire into any charges against the PM. The Janta Party Government took a serious note and introduced the amended Bill, which brought the PM within the orbit of inquiry by the Lokpal. Alas! The government was ejaculated prematurely out of the power without taking the pleasure of being in the centre for long. And finally the Bill lapsed with the dissolution of the Lower House.

The Rajeev Gandhi government revived the proposal and introduced the Bill in Parliament in 1985. But this could not be enacted (If you remember Rajiv Gandhi Government had 403 MP’s and the Congress Party had its governments in more than two-third of states. With such a sweeping majority, they could have possibly changed the entire Constitution). The short-lived Janta Dal governments, firstly in 1989 and again in 1996, couldn’t contribute anything to the Bill. They were fighting for their own survival and struggling to keep their farmer PM awake. Likewise, the nationalist BJP had some other plans. They wanted to keep its Face above the rest. And in result, on the recommendation of the National Commission on the Constitution headed by Congress dissident, P.A. Sangma, the BJP government kept PM out of the purview of the Lokpal. Sadly, the BJP government had ambitions of a million men with the willpower of none. The Bill lapsed again in 2004. We should thank Anna for reviving the issue, bringing it to the centre stage of politics again and compelling the government to make some sincere commitments. Shouldn’t we?


Since 1966 (the year ARC recommended the formation of Lokpal), we have seen scams of all kinds –big, small, political, apolitical, civilian, military, corporate, labour, etc. But you cannot deny the fact that no serious attempt has been made to curb corruption. Political parties fight but to win elections. They have never taken a serious attempt against large scale grafts. Their target has always been the corrupt for mischievous political gains. And this is the failure of our political system.